Saturday, October 5, 2013

Business Model Analysis Report


“We work with visionary companies. Ambitious companies. Companies that stand for something and companies that want to transcend their categories and be a positive force in people’s lives.

About GSD&M:
GSD&M is a full service advertising agency in Austin that was founded by four graduates of The University of Texas. It is part of the Publicis Omnicom Group which is one of the biggest agencies in America that provides advertising, marketing, and corporate communications in its services. GSD&M has done work for several well-known and respected companies such as Walgreens, John Deere, Goodyear, and Southwest Airlines. GSD&M specializes in a conglomerate of marketing aspects including online/social media campaigns, website creation, integrated production, re-branding, and media planning, just to name a few. According to Austin Business Journal, GSD&M is both the largest and the best advertising agency in Austin based on its largest gross income of $67 million dollars a year. It’s most recognizable work: “Don’t Mess With Texas”. What started as an anti-littering campaign for the Texas Department of Transportation not only decreased litter by 72% in 10 years, but quickly also became the slogan of Texas and its proud citizens.

The people who work at GSD&M are passionate. And because of this, they work with passionate companies using “purpose-based branding”. What does this mean? It means they consider identifying what the company wishes to change about the world the most important factor in building a relationship with clients in order for GSD&M to properly create for them.
Why GSD&M is of interest to me:
In Austin, GSD&M is a home away from home for hundreds of creative professionals, and the company is known for its diverse and informal, yet professional company culture. I have already moved away from Austin twice in my life, and after the last time I knew I could never leave again. As a marketing student who is about to graduate in May, I already have been excitedly and hesitantly thinking about where I am going to jump start my career. Since I will be looking for a marketing job in Austin in the (too) near future, I want to use this business report to help me learn more about this advertising agency and the marketing climate in Austin. If I find what it offers exciting, and think its business model is respectable, then I would like to pursue an entry level job there and having done this report will give me a knowledgeable edge when applying there.
Customer segments and their value propositions:
When looking at the online list of GSD&M’s past clients, I identified three main customer segments: retail stores, manufacturers, and companies that sell services. According to our text book, Business Model Generation, GSD&M uses customer segments rather than diversified, niche, mass, or multi sided-platform segment types. This is because it serves customers with similar needs but also with significantly different relationships, product offerings, profits, distribution channels, and wants.  I am going to briefly discuss the individual value proposition of each of these segments. Value propositions are one of the nine basic building blocks “that show the logic of how a company intends to make money”.  On their website, GSD&M states “Our Purpose is to do whatever it takes to grow our clients’ business so that they can fulfill their Purpose.While this is GSD&M’s universal goal, they apply it to each customer segment differently by offering each one different value.

GSD&M works with retail stores such as Walgreens, Marshalls, Zale’s, Ace Hardware, and Popeye’s. While these companies all offer several different types of products and have different strategies for selling them, they all have the goal of wanting to increase the value their products offer and therefore also increase their profits by having more people shop and purchase in their physical and online retail spaces. These companies often do not produce their own products but instead specialize in creating an appealing, convenient, and enjoyable shopping experience. Therefore, the value proposition of GSD&M to its retail store customers is to create marketing strategies that will bring more people into their stores.
Examples of manufacturers that GSD&M works with include Goodyear, John Deere, Campbell’s, Lee, Jarritos, and Pacifico. These companies differ from the other two segments because they are experts in production, manufacturing, design, and packaging of products. They do not specialize in retail spaces and therefore often don’t sell directly to the public. Despite this, in some ways these companies must have multi-sided marketing strategies because they must appeal to consumers and also businesses: retail stores will only want to place these products on their show room floors and shelves if their customers will buy them. The value proposition of GSD&M for manufacturing companies is to create marketing strategies that will increase the number of stores selling their product and the number of people who buy those products.
The last customer segment, service providing companies, includes companies such as Southwest Airlines, The University of Texas, Austin City Limits, AT&T, and Sports Clips. These companies offer varying services from education to entertainment to lawyers. While the services are diverse, the products they sell are all intangible. They must convince customers to pay for something that they may not physically take home but will receive benefits from. This is often a losing battle when it comes to health services or insurance—it’s hard for people to be willing to pay a lot for these intangibles. Therefore, GSD&M’s value proposition for service providers is to create marketing strategies that help customers see the value in their intangible offerings.
Concerns:

While I am very excited about studying GSD&M in my market report, I worry that these customer segments are not different enough in their needs to qualify as actual segments. I see their basic underlying need for all of them is to increase profit. I also could not find ways to distinguish between the different segments trough the values discussed in the Business Model Generation text book (newness, performance, customization, price, design, etc.) because I think GSD&M offers the same values in these areas to each segment.

1 comment:

  1. Hi Kathleen. I think you’ve done a good job identifying three customers out of such a large firm as well as identifying the value proposition. I understand and empathize with your concerns and its smart of you to point them out and look to address them early. Maybe think of it beyond the act of creating “marketing strategies.” Or de-couple the components of a marketing strategy to the portions of it that each customer segment really cares about. For instance, with retail stores, its more than just bringing people in to their stores – its also bringing them the right kind of people.

    ReplyDelete